Unreasonable complainant behaviour policy

1. Policy statement

1.1.   This policy sets out our approach to the very few customers whose actions or behaviour is considered unacceptable while we are considering their complaint.

1.2.   Occasionally, the behaviour or actions of individuals makes it very difficult for us to deal with their complaint. In a small number of cases the actions of individuals become unacceptable.

1. 3    When this happens, we must take action to protect the health and wellbeing of our colleagues who have a right to do their jobs without fear of being abused or harassed. We also consider the impact of the behaviour on our ability to do our work and provide a service to others.

1.4.   Complaints are a valuable source of feedback and support us to improve service delivery. This policy is not intended to prevent customers from raising legitimate and important concerns, enquiries or requests, or pursuing them.

1.5.   This policy has been assessed in line with our equality impact assessment to ensure there are no direct or indirect detrimental impacts on our customers.

2. Policy aims

2.1.    The aim of this policy is to:

  • make it clear to all complainants, both at initial contact and throughout their dealings with us, what we can or cannot do in relation to their case; in doing so, we aim to be open and not raise hopes or expectations that cannot be met
  • deal fairly, honestly, consistently, and appropriately with all complainants, including those whose actions are considered unacceptable; we believe that everyone who approaches us has the right to be heard, understood, and respected and that our employees have the same rights
  • provide a service that is accessible to everyone, while retaining the right to restrict or change such access where complainant actions are considered unacceptable
  • ensure that other complainants and employees do not suffer any disadvantage from complainants that act in an unacceptable manner
  • act in accordance with the Housing Ombudsman’s Complaints Handling Code and best practice
  • ensure that any restrictions applied are proportionate in the circumstances
  • ensure a framework for review is in place
  • ensure we comply with the Equality Act 2010
  • ensure we comply with the Data Protection Act 2018 ensuring that confidential. data is treated in accordance with legislation.

3. Defining unacceptable actions

3.1      People may act out of character in times of trouble or distress. There may have been upsetting or distressing circumstances leading up to them contacting us. We do not view this behaviour as unacceptable just because someone is forceful or determined. However, the actions of complainants that are angry, demanding, or excessively persistent may result in unreasonable demands on, or unacceptable behaviour towards employees. It is these actions that are considered unacceptable, and we aim to manage under this policy.

Aggressive or abusive behaviour

3.2      We understand that many customers are often upset and angry about the issues they have raised in their complaint. If that anger escalates into aggression towards our people, we consider that unacceptable. Any violence or abuse towards colleagues will not be tolerated.

3.3      Violence is not restricted to acts of physical aggression. It also includes behaviour or language (whether verbal or written) that may cause colleagues to feel offended, afraid, threatened or abused. While we accept that those who contact us may feel frustrated or upset, it is not acceptable to shout or swear at us.

3.4      We consider language is unacceptable when it:

  • is offensive, derogatory, or patronising
  • is discriminatory in any way, including racist, sexist, homophobic or transphobic comments.

Abusive and threatening behaviour towards employees will be treated as antisocial behaviour and dealt with in accordance with our Antisocial Behaviour Policy and/or Person of Interest Policy.

This policy is different from our Person of Interest Policy. It is designed to help us manage situations where a customer’s behaviour during a complaint, enquiry, or service request makes it difficult for us to provide an effective service to them or other customers. The Person of Interest Policy is only used where there are concerns about the safety or wellbeing of our colleagues, customers, contractors, or others. In some cases, both policies may apply, but this will be considered carefully based on the individual circumstances. Applying either policy will not affect a customer’s right to access our services or have their concerns considered fairly.

Unreasonable, unacceptable or excessive demands

3.5      A demand becomes unacceptable when it starts to (or when complying with the demand would) impact substantially on the work of the service and our ability to meet timescales. Examples of this behaviour include:

  • repeatedly demanding a response within an unreasonable timescale
  • insisting on seeing or speaking to a particular colleague, when that is not possible
  • repeatedly changing the substance of a complaint or raising unrelated concerns
  • seeking to have colleagues that are dealing with a complaint, replaced, without sufficient grounds
  • providing trivial or irrelevant information with an expectation that each point is commented on or raising large numbers of detailed but unimportant questions and insisting they are all fully answered
  • refusing to accept a decision where reasonable explanations for the decision have been provided and any appeals processes exhausted
  • repeatedly requesting Data Subject Access Requests when information has already been provided by the Data Protection Team.

3.6      An example of such impact would be that the demand takes up an excessive amount of employee time and, in doing so, disadvantages other customers and prevents their own complaint from being dealt with quickly.

Unreasonable, unacceptable, and persistent levels of contact

3.7      Sometimes the volume and duration of contact made to us by an individual is too much and can cause problems. This can occur over a short period but may also occur over the lifespan of a complaint.

3.8      We consider that the level of contact has become unacceptable when the amount of time spent talking to a customer on the telephone, or responding to, reviewing, and filing emails or written correspondence impacts on our ability to deal with that complaint, or with other customers’ complaints.

Examples of unacceptable or persistent levels of contact include:

  • making repeated and unnecessary contact during the course of us dealing with a complaint or carrying out an investigation
  • repeated telephone calls over a short period; for example, a high number calls in one day or week
  • lengthy telephone calls repeating the same points of discussion
  • high volumes of information provided by email or post referencing the same issues
  • unnecessarily or excessively copying us into emails.

Harassment

3.9      We have the right to carry out our duties free from harassment or threats of harassment. We ask all customers to respect that we are delivering services and communication decisions on behalf of believe housing and this may not reflect our own views or preferences.

Examples of behaviours we consider to be harassment against our colleagues include:

  • recording telephone discussions without permission
  • contacting colleagues using their personal details or social media presence such as Facebook, Twitter or LinkedIn
  • publishing personal, sensitive, or private information about colleagues online or other public domains such as noticeboards or newsletters
  • repeated unsubstantiated allegations made against our colleagues
  • making inflammatory statements or raising unsubstantiated allegations about third parties such as a contractor working on our behalf
  • making serious allegations that individuals have committed criminal, corrupt, or perverse conduct without any evidence.

Refusal to cooperate

3.10    When we are looking at a complaint, we will need to ask the individual who has complained to work with us. This can include:

  • helping us to ‘define’ the complaint, to ensure we fully understand any concerns, and can resolve the complaint appropriately
  • providing us with further information, evidence, or comments on request without delay.

3.11    Sometimes, an individual repeatedly refuses to cooperate, or continually changes the focus of the original complaint to prolong the engagement and this makes it difficult for us to proceed.

3.12    We will always seek to assist or make reasonable adjustments for a customer if they have a specific difficulty complying with a request. However, it is unacceptable to make a complaint to us and then not respond to clear and appropriate requests from us.

3.13    In these circumstances, we will proceed with the complaint based on the information we have available, we will make it clear in the complaint outcome letter that the customer was uncooperative.

3.14    Should we not have enough information to proceed with a complaint, the customer will be informed in writing.

3.15    We will adhere to the Housing Ombudsman’s Complaint Handling Code and seek their guidance, if appropriate.

 

4. Reasonable adjustments

4.1      In accordance with the Equality Act 2010 we recognise that some complainants may have disabilities, such as challenging mental health or learning disabilities, that can make it difficult for them to express themselves or communicate clearly, particularly if they are anxious or upset. Likewise, we realise that some disabilities can make it difficult for complainants to assess the impact their behaviour may have on others.

4.2      We will always consider making reasonable adjustments for a disabled or vulnerable customer if asked to do so. This may include using different methods of communication and giving clear warnings as soon as the behaviour becomes unacceptable so that the complainant can change it. However, it is not reasonable for employees to be subjected to aggressive, offensive, or abusive actions, language, or behaviour. We may still use the policy if there are actions or behaviours which are having a negative effect on our colleagues or our work, even where a reasonable adjustment has been made.

4.3      Before taking any action under this policy, we will liaise with any known support workers or providers that may liaise or work in partnership with other agencies, if appropriate.

5. Actions we may take

5.1    When we experience unacceptable, unreasonable behaviour or demands, we may consider taking more formal action. The actions we will consider can include:

  • giving clear warnings if conversations become unproductive and allowing customers the opportunity to modify behaviour
  • taking immediate action to terminate a call where it is appropriate in the circumstances
  • formally warning the customer about their behaviour and requesting that the customer modifies their behaviour in future contact with us
  • only taking telephone calls from the complainant at set times and/or on set days
  • requiring the person to nominate a family member, friend, or support worker to contact us on their behalf
  • reading and filing future correspondence but not replying or acknowledging receipt unless it relates to a new and unrelated complaint
  • deciding not to investigate a complaint on the basis that it has been pursued in a way that is unacceptable
  • re-routing email correspondence to one single inbox
  • taking other action that we consider appropriate.

5.2.    In exceptional circumstances, we may:

  • notify relevant public authorities, and/or
  • take formal action in accordance with the tenancy agreement.

Before we take action

5.3.   Before we apply this policy, a case conference will be held and documented with clear decision-making and consideration around our duties under the relevant legislation, while considering any known vulnerabilities in line with our Vulnerability Policy.

5.4.   The proportionality and impact of any restrictions imposed will be examined and considered during the conference. Those present will agree if any restrictions should be timebound. The relevant service area manager will be responsible for reviewing any timebound restrictions.

6. Reconsideration and complaints

6.1    A customer can ask for a restriction to be reconsidered in any of the following circumstances:

  • where there is a change in circumstances which mean the managed behaviour restriction is no longer appropriate
  • where there is evidence the restriction impacts the customer’s ability to access our services
  • a factual error was made by our service when making the decision to apply the restriction
  • if a customer is dissatisfied with the application of this policy, they must follow the formal complaints process.

 

7. Relevant policies and procedures

  • Complaints, Compensation and Compliments Policy
  • Antisocial Behaviour Policy
  • Person of Interest Procedure
  • Safeguarding Policy
  • Accident and Incident Reporting Procedure
  • Vulnerability Policy
  • Work-related Violence and Aggression Policy

This policy was reviewed and updated in October 2026.